We never expected to make a film about Metallica. We thought this
was going to be a little straight-to-video promo about the making of
Metallica’s new album. Three years and 1,600 hours of footage
later, we realized we had something entirely different on our hands.
We first met Metallica when we started editing Paradise
Lost, our film about the 1993 killings of three young boys in
West Memphis, Arkansas. In that story, three innocent teenagers were
targeted by police and wrongfully convicted of the murders, partly because
they listened to Metallica and other heavy metal bands. We thought it
would be interesting to use this music as the soundtrack to our film,
since heavy metal was implicitly being put on trial along with these
kids (the lyrics to “Sanitarium” were actually introduced
as “evidence” in the case). Metallica had never allowed
their music to be used in a film before, but we figured it couldn't
hurt to ask—the worst that could happen is they'd tell us to take
a hike. So we faxed a letter to their management company Q Prime, and
were completely shocked when the phone rang an hour later. Metallica’s
manager Cliff Burnstein told us that the band had enjoyed our film Brother’s
Keeper, truly felt for everyone involved in the West Memphis
case, and would like to help us out. We were thrilled (and surprised
that they had even heard of Brother’s Keeper,
much less seen it), but still apprehensive because we figured it would
cost us our entire post-production budget to pay for the songs. Then
they said we could have the songs for free. Who were these guys?
Fast-forward six years. We’d kept in touch with Metallica, and
had vaguely discussed doing something together a few times. We shot
them for a VH-1 show (and they gave us more music for Revelations:
Paradise Lost 2), but a larger project never materialized. We
talked about making a documentary about them, but only if they were
willing to give us total access to their private world. They understood,
but that wasn’t something they were prepared to do. Then in early
2001, Lars Ulrich (Metallica’s drummer) said, “Maybe we’re
ready to do something now.”
Their bass player Jason Newsted had just left the band, but they were
about to record a new album, so Elektra Records (Metallica’s label)
commissioned a short promo film to document the sessions. When we started
shooting, it became clear that the band members were not getting along
very well. The band began group therapy with a performance enhancement
coach, Phil Towle, in an effort to facilitate communication. To our
surprise, they agreed to our request to film the sessions.
A few months into shooting, James Hetfield (Metallica’s lead
singer) checked himself into rehab and didn’t come back for almost
a year. No one knew if he was going to come back, or if this was the
end of Metallica, and nobody really knew what to do. Lars and Kirk Hammett
(Metallica’s lead guitarist) didn’t know, Q Prime didn’t
know, and Elektra didn’t know. Neither did we, so we just kept
on shooting.
What had started out as a little promo was becoming a whole lot more.
The band was going through monumental personal and professional changes.
We were, too. After shooting Metallica’s intense therapy sessions,
we often found ourselves back at the hotel, hashing out our own fifteen-year
relationship.
When Metallica was finally getting ready to finish and release the
album they’d spent over two years making (and we’d spent
over two years documenting), Elektra decided they wanted us to turn
our footage into a multi-part series for television. By now though,
we knew we had a movie.
We showed the band some scenes we’d cut, and they agreed. Elektra
graciously allowed Metallica to take over the film, and the band bought
out the project with their own money. Metallica gave us the dough to
finish shooting and editing, and left us to our own devices. It was
pretty unbelievable—the biggest hard rock band of all time had
bared their souls to each other and our cameras for two and a half of
the most intense years of their lives, and they gave us final cut! All
they said was, “We trust you. Do what you want, just be truthful.”
A lot of this movie isn’t pretty, but we think we we’re
truthful. Every film we’ve made has taken us to unexpected places,
but Metallica: Some Kind of Monster, has been
a truly amazing journey.
—New York City